Little Women 1949

Even after 5 more installments of the little women, the one from 1949 is still worth watching. It is probably closest to the spirit of the book. There are silent ones from 1917 and 1918 which I have not seen. My personal favorite is the 1994 one with Christian Bale as Laurie. The later ones experiment with "time travel". The 2019 one is still acceptable but I personally do not like "shuffling of time" just for the sake of novelty. This classical story should be told in the way it was written. There is a contemporary film adaptation from 2018 which I would clearly rate the worst. (Box office and review confirm this). It is almost comic how the 2018 adaptation tries to place Joe as a victim of social bias. There is a scene where her writing is dismissed by 4 dislikable (horrific actually) male judges. This is quite opposite to the original source: the character "Joe" was early recognized as a successful writer. Joe could sell her stories in the local newspaper and landed a major hit eventually. She was recognized as a talent by the "professor". How many young adults have such luck in modern times? Especially now, where creativity is devalued almost daily by artificial intelligence and the work of artists, writers, musicians, engineers and scientists is siphoned into large language models and then stolen by folks who have little creativity themselves, often without giving credit. The author of "little women", Louisa May Alcott, was in 1858 already a best seller writing and immensely successful, unlike Emily Dickinson who was born a bit earlier and not so lucky. The teacher in the scene below from the 1949 installment is a bit off putting. The calculation 197+283+465 = 945 is seen on the board. The numbers above 7:28::9:? is a bit mysterious. It might refer to a date like July 28? Amy standing with the board reading "I'm ashamed of myself" seems to be placed in as a card board. It looks flat and only moves very rigidly. Could also have been painted or glued into the film. One can see some reflections which also indicate that it might have been taped to the film. Quite awkward. They tried to be close to the book, where Amy was punished in school by standing in front of the class with a clothespin clipped to her nose.

M4V, Ogg Webm. IMBd link

Oliver Knill, Posted April 10, 2026 ,